The following letter to the editor, written by HAF Board of Advisors member Vishal Agarwal, providing commentary on the Saint Paul city council’s pending Resolution 20-712 was submitted to the Star Tribune on May 7, 2020.

As a resident of Minnesota for more than 20 years, I am astonished that, in the midst of the still-raging coronavirus pandemic, the St. Paul City Council has chosen to table Resolution 20-712,  needlessly bringing divisive international politics to our city and that too on the basis of faulty and one-sided information.

The initial draft of this resolution alleges that the recent riots in Delhi consisted solely of Hindu mobs wantonly lynching Muslims — even though Hindus and Sikhs lives too were lost at the hands of Muslim mobs — and that the Government of India is about to strip citizenship from its 200 million Muslims through the Citizenship Amendment Act, the National Population Register and the National Register of Citizens.

What the CAA does is nothing like Resolution 20-712 claims.

The fact of the matter is that CAA expedites citizenship for six minority religious communities fleeing well-documented and persistent persecution in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, and Pakistan and who have been living as stateless people in India for some time. It has no effect on current citizens of India, regardless of religion. It does not prohibit immigration to India by Muslims of any nation applying through normal channels, full stop.

The Resolution also blatantly fails to understand that the National Population Register (NPR) has nothing to do with citizenship per se, instead being just a census carried out every decade, for the past century and a half.

As for the National Register of Citizens (NRC), it is still not defined and was implemented only reluctantly by the Indian government in a single state, due to a directive by the Supreme Court of India after a petition was filed when the Congress Party (the previous government) was in power.

In short, a national NRC does not really exist.

And it strains credulity to imagine a scenario where the Muslim population of India — all 200 million of them — are stripped of citizenship due to not being able to produce birth certificates and other documentation that many Indians do not possess, regardless of religion, including my well-educated, middle class parents.

Instead of antagonizing India, the largest democracy in the world with secularism strongly enshrined in its constitution, a better use of the city council’s time would be to examine why members of minority religious communities are being forced to flee neighboring nations.

Furthermore, the secretive way in which Resolution 20-172 was introduced is deeply problematic.

The Resolution claims to speak up for the South Asian community. I am an active volunteer for several broad-based community organizations, Indian and Hindu, and few of my contacts were aware of the resolution and those who were aware had their concerns brushed aside. Rather, the city council relied, apparently, on just two Muslim organizations to draft the resolution. Excluding South Asian Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Zoroastrians, and Baha’is from this process nullifies any claim that the resolution is speaking for local South Asians as a whole.

There are 50,000 people of Indian origin in the Twin Cities. Resolution 20-172 creates an unnecessarily hostile environment for Hindus here, and now we’re forced to dispel the many untruths and stereotypes the St. Paul City Council has perpetuated.

I hope that the city council, rather than wading into an arena of geopolitics it clearly knows little to nothing about, focuses on ensuring a brighter future for all Minnesotans.

About the Author: Vishal Agarwal is a member of the Advisory Board of the Hindu American Foundation and on the Trustee Executive Council of the Hindu Society of Minnesota.


  • Great work by Mr. Agarwal.

  • Neer Bhardwaj says:

    I hope that the city council, rather than wading into an arena of geopolitics it clearly knows little to nothing about, focuses on ensuring a brighter future for all Minnesotans.

  • Sushmi Aggarwal says:

    Very complete and thoroughly researched

  • Sandeep Singh says:

    I agree with Vishal Agarwal. This is misleading information. I lived in US more than 16 yrs now and almost 7 yrs in Minnesota. We need to stop the people who present false information to promote their religion. We all are human and India welcome to practice all regions similar to US. Hindu teaches .. peace and prosperity. CAA is a human kindness to the people who have been neglected abroad as mentioned earlier based on their religion. India took an initiative to give them space for human kind. Salute to India for human thinking and always thinks well for human!

  • Swathi Prasad Dora says:

    Appreciate your action in conveying tha facts and we wish you success .

  • Hindus from pakistan,bangladesh afganistan and not welcomed or given refugees status in canada ,europe and US.Muslim refugees from all muslims war effected countries are welcomed.Why there is discrimination ? If minorities in afganistan,Bangladesh and pakistan are not welcomed anywhere in the world and if India is ready to give citizenship to minorities from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan what is the Problem ?

  • Ashok Chadha says:

    It is a joint concipiracy of Christians, Muslims and Pakistan. We are happy that you are opposing these sinister designs of anti Indians. We in India and you there have to face them and expose them.

  • Puran Rathod says:

    Ilhan Omer is the senetor,well known for her anti-Semitism. She speaks openly against Trump administration.

  • Mithi says:

    A very misleading inaccurate information which has created a sense of distrust among the followers of different Faiths . This anomaly must be rectified immediately

Leave a Reply