Why the New History Standards in Virginia Matter and Why There's Much More to Be Done - Hindu American Foundation
Education

Why the New History Standards in Virginia Matter and Why There’s Much More to Be Done

By March 30, 2015 November 7th, 2019 One Comment

For over a decade, Hindu Americans have been active across the country in trying to get schools and textbooks to present a more accurate assessment of Hinduism.

That’s because Hinduism is often lumped into the history textbooks’ coverage of ancient India, and the grossly inaccurate narrative goes something like this: Aryans migrated into (or invaded) the Indian subcontinent and established Hinduism and the caste system. Hinduism then gets “replaced” by more progressive religions like Buddhism and virtually disappears from mention from history.

As I’ve noted, the complex, diverse, and adaptive global history of Hinduism has been grossly misrepresented for years, and the efforts by Hindu Americans – particularly parents – to get better representation of the faith has been a response to decades of seeing their children bullied in schools. As a second-generation Hindu-American who was bullied constantly, made to feel like an inferior Other, and put on the spot to explain my religious beliefs to my classmates, I never want my future children to have to deal with that trauma. Of course, there are many who share those traumatic experiences.

When the Virginia Board of Education voted last week to adopt new history and social science standards of learning, the revised standards on ancient India were groundbreaking. For the first time, standards of learning in a state refer to the Aryan migrations as in dispute, allowing for a healthier debate on ancient Indian origins. Moreover, Hindu philosophy is also given its own standard line, allowing for an exploration of Hindu beliefs without being tied to Indian history.

The process took over a year, and HAF was involved from the start. We submitted public comments, met with Virginia Department of Education staff to the point where we hugged every time we saw each other, and met with individual board members to explain our concerns about the way the old standards were worded. Virginia education officials were already somewhat attuned to our concerns, since a group of Hindu Virginians traveled to Richmond in 2008 during the Commonwealth’s last curriculum frameworks revision, which is what educators call the “meat and potatoes” of education content. Their efforts led to major changes in the curriculum frameworks and made it easier to help revise the content standards.

Virginia is one of just a handful of states that still do statewide standards of learning and curriculum frameworks adoptions. The standards are the skeleton of what students should learn, while the frameworks are the substantive muscle. These processes are tied to each other and ultimately shape what Virginia students learn after new textbooks are adopted.

Whenever I spoke with Virginia Department of Education staff, they were not only receptive to the information we provided, but were willing to seek out the expertise of academics who could vouch for our comments. The consensus on issues such as Aryan migrations has shifted significantly in the past decade, and we noted that the standards should reflect that shift.

The other inaccurate reference in the old standard was caste. While it is true that the development of a varni/jati system was (and is) a significant part of Indian social history, most textbooks oversimplified and distorted this intricate and non-rigid system into a static and discriminatory “caste” system that it is only practiced by Hindus. In fact, the way caste is described today has nothing to do with Hindu scriptures, which do not sanction caste-based discrimination, and as such, the depictions in content standards and classrooms are deeply problematic.

By removing emphasis on the caste system in the standard (which has been part of the distorted narrative about Hinduism in textbooks) and acknowledging the dispute over the Aryan migration, the Board set the stage for a more robust and accurate understanding of Indian history and Hinduism. They also provided a template by which other states, including California – which is undergoing its own frameworks revision – can highlight these issues in a fair, balanced, culturally sensitive and accurate way. It’s just another step in a long process for greater equity in how Hinduism is depicted in education content and the way the Hindu American community is treated.

In that regard, the Virginia vote – just like the Texas textbook adoption – is a major positive step toward ensuring that Hinduism is treated as a diverse living tradition in the same way that other world faiths are in our schools.

 

One Comment

  • Great work by Professor Balaji of the Hindu American Foundation and the Virginia Board of Education! No doubt this will lead to less bullying and a better all around understanding of India and Hinduism.

Leave a Reply

10/28/22Dr. Anandibai Joshi

Dr. Anandi Gopal Joshi is credited with being the first woman from India to study medicine in the United States. Born in Bombay in 1865, she was married at the age of ten to an older man who had been her teacher. Dr. Joshi had a child at the age of 13, but the child died when only 10 days old. She believed that with better medical care, the child would have lived, and she frequently cited this as motivation for her desire to attend medical school. Her husband encouraged her in her academic pursuits and in 1883, Joshee joined the Woman’s Medical College of Pennsylvania, now known as the Drexel University College of Medicine in Philadelphia. She graduated in 1886 with her degree in medicine; her M.D. thesis focused on Hindu obstetrics. Unfortunately,  Dr. Joshi was only able to practice medicine for a few months before passing away from tuberculosis.

Science in Hinduism

10/2/2022Gandhi Jayanti

Gandhi Jayanti marks the birthday of Mahatma Gandhi, the ‘Father of the Nation’ for India and the Indian Diaspora. To honor Gandhi’s message of ahimsa (non-violence), volunteer events and commemorative ceremonies are conducted and statues of Gandhi are also decorated with flower garlands. Gandhi and the satyagraha (truth force) has inspired many of America’s most prominent civil rights and social impact movements and leaders, including Martin Luther King Jr., and Cesar Chavez. The United Nations declared October 2 as the International Day of Non-Violence in honor of Gandhi, whose work continues to inspire civil rights movements across the world.

Examining the Impact of Mahatma Gandhi on Social Change Movements

Why we should not tear down statues of Gandhi

10/1/2022First Hindu temple in US

The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 facilitated the journey of many Indian immigrants to the United States. In this new land, many created home shrines and community temples to practice and hold pujas (services). As Hindu American populations grew in metropolitan and rural areas, so did the need to find a permanent temple site for worship. In 1906, the Vedanta Society built the Old Temple in San Francisco, California but as this was not considered a formal temple, many don’t credit this with being the first. Others believe it is the Shiva Murugan Temple built in 1957 in Concord, California, whereas others believe it is the Maha Vallabha Ganapati Devanstanam in New York that should be considered the first. Today, there are nearly 1,000 temples in the United States . Regardless of where you live, you have the right to practice your faith.

A Guide To Temple Safety and Security

5 Things to Know About Visiting a Hindu Temple